The Surprising Decision: Donating instead of Inheriting

My brother, who sadly passed away in June, made a rather unexpected decision regarding his estate. Instead of leaving his belongings to his siblings, he chose to donate everything - his home, furnishings, and the remaining cash - to charity. This decision has left us all surprised and bewildered. While he did leave a will clearly outlining his wishes, the question arises: can this will be contested?

Understanding His Choice

It's natural to be taken aback by such surprising actions, and we all prefer to have answers rather than question marks. Perhaps you had a good relationship with your brother, without any reason to assume any conflicts between him and his siblings. In such cases, it's best to remember that people's choices often have little to do with us personally. Don't take it as a reflection on your relationship.

Contesting a Will: Exploring the Possibilities

There are instances when contesting a will may be appropriate, such as in cases where a parent is unduly influenced by a new person in their life or an abusive child. It could also apply when someone is forced to change their will under compromised mental capacity. However, in your brother's case, it appears that he made a conscious decision and knew exactly what he was doing. His intention was to support his favorite charities.

Need vs. Want: Love vs. Money

Your personal desire to inherit money from your brother may not align with his belief that others are in greater need and require more assistance. It's important to note that you haven't mentioned experiencing any dire financial hardship in your letter. This was his way of giving back. Remember, the absence of financial inheritance does not indicate a lack of love. By honoring his final wishes, you can demonstrate your love for him even more.

"You are not direct heirs (a parent or child); as siblings, you are collateral descendants."

Contesting a Will: Grounds and Possibilities

Generally, a will can be contested based on three grounds: lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence from a family member, and improper execution. The latter is often the easiest and most common way a will is contested or overturned. For example, if the will was not properly witnessed or signed, if a later will exists, or if there is evidence of fraud.

In summary, while the decision to donate instead of inheriting may be surprising, it's essential to respect your brother's wishes and his generosity towards his favorite causes. Contemplating contesting the will may only bring further uncertainty and discontent. Instead, embrace his legacy by supporting his chosen charities and remembering the love he had for his siblings.

The Importance of Clear Communication in Wills

Your brother's will did not explicitly mention the family, raising questions of whether he intended to disinherit them or if it was simply an oversight. Sometimes, individuals state their intent to disinherit their family members or leave them a token amount with the condition that they forfeit even that if they contest the will. However, this does not seem to be the case here.

As collateral descendants rather than direct heirs like a parent or child, you and your siblings may argue that your absence from the will was an unintentional omission. Nevertheless, considering that your brother's will appears to be valid and there are no indications of any irregularities, it is advisable to respect his wishes. Feeling upset about not inheriting his estate is not sufficient grounds to contest the will.

While it is natural to have questions and concerns regarding wills and inheritances, seeking clarity and understanding can help alleviate some of the uncertainty. By having open and honest discussions with family members and consulting legal professionals, you can ensure that everyone's wishes and expectations are properly addressed.

Join Our Community

Do you have questions about money matters and need expert advice? Join the Moneyist private Facebook group, where we tackle life's most challenging financial dilemmas. Our readers submit various complex situations, and we do our best to provide insightful answers. Share your questions, let us know what topics interest you, or engage in conversations about recent Moneyist columns.

• 'I have no guilt': My stepfather plans to leave me his $1 million home. How can I protect my inheritance from his biological children?
• 'I spend $600 a month taking women out for dinner and drinks': Navigating the etiquette of who pays on a first date
• My brother helps pay for our mother's mortgage and co-owns her home. How can I ensure fair distribution of the inheritance among siblings?